The Sony WF-1000XM4 true wi-fi earbuds are right here, and there’s little doubt they’re a giant enchancment over the prior model, the WF-1000XM3. However are they ok to take down the AirPods Professional as my go-to wi-fi buds?
Whereas the AirPods Professional are removed from good — they don’t have one of the best sound, one of the best battery life, one of the best noise-canceling — by some means they turned my go-to earbuds. Time to mow the garden? I seize the AirPods Professional. Zoom assembly arising? AirPods Professional. However why?
I feel it’s as a result of whereas they aren’t the perfect at anyone factor, they nonetheless do fairly nicely at nearly every part. That’s, they’re well-rounded and reliable. I’ve obtained 9 different pairs of true wi-fi buds I actually take pleasure in, however every of these let me down indirectly, which is why I hold coming again to the AirPods Professional. However with improved battery life, higher noise canceling, and superior sound, do the Sony WF-1000XM4 have what it takes for me to lastly shelve the AirPods Professional? Let’s discover out.
Kind and match
Let’s begin with the obvious factor, which is the form of the buds. Since we’re all fairly acquainted with the AirPods Professional by now, let’s deal with the Sony XM4. You’ll discover they appear like … earbuds! That’s an enormous enchancment over the earlier model, which I all the time felt have been cumbersome and awkward and seemed a bit of an excessive amount of like these old-school Bluetooth headsets we used to rock again within the day. So proper off the bat, the XM4 are already extra aggressive with the AirPods Professional than the XM3 have been, and by way of appears to be like alone, I want the Sony.
Simon Cohen / Digital Traits
However now we have to transfer on to the match. The AirPods Professional use silicone eartips, and I’ve by no means had an issue with them becoming in my ear and staying fairly safe. Additionally they present a good seal for me, which is vital for sound high quality — you get higher bass with an excellent seal — in addition to passive noise isolation and lively noise canceling.
The XM4, curiously sufficient, include foam eartips solely. Now, in my expertise, foam eartips present one of the best seal for blocking out noise, however they have a tendency to roll off the excessive frequencies within the sound. So to fight that lack of treble, the earbuds have to be voiced with a bit of additional treble coming from the drivers inside so it sounds balanced after the froth ideas do what they do to the sound. And I’ll undoubtedly get to the sound high quality quickly.
There’s one other facet to suit that we have to discuss and that has to do with how the bud sits within the ear. With the AirPods Professional, the round a part of the bud is fairly small, so it doesn’t actually come into play by way of how the buds match and really feel. They’re going to be snug for nearly everybody, save these with super-tiny ears.
By way of match, the AirPods Professional take the win.
The Sony XM4 are a bit totally different in that they’re designed to suit snugly within the ears proper within the concha — that’s the cavity on the innermost a part of the outer ear that funnels to the ear canal. It’s actually laborious to foretell how that is going to work for any given individual’s ears as a result of this part of the ear may be massive in small ears or small in massive ears. So, finally, how the Sony XM4 really feel goes to be distinctive from individual to individual. For that purpose, I strongly urge you to attempt them on in the event you can, or simply purchase from a retailer with a strong return coverage simply in case they don’t really feel good to you. Additionally, the XM4 are bulkier and heavier.
So, by way of match, the AirPods Professional take the win — however I nonetheless want how the Sony XM4 look, and so they match me simply positive.
Case and battery life
Now let’s check out the case. The XM4’s case obtained slimmed down considerably from the XM3’s, and it’s extra rounded now, which I like. It additionally helps wi-fi charging, which was lacking from the XM3’s case. Each the XM4 and AirPods Professional instances are simply pocketable, and so they each maintain the buds securely with magnets. However the case can also be there as a battery to recharge the buds, so let’s get into battery life.
Simon Cohen / Digital Traits
Only a reminder: The AirPods Professional will go for about four-and-a-half hours with ANC on and about 5 hours with it off earlier than needing a cost within the case, and with the case, you may get about 24 hours complete earlier than it is advisable recharge the entire package.
The Sony XM4 blow these numbers out of the water. With the XM4, you’ll get about eight hours with ANC on, 12 hours with ANC off, and with the case, you’ll get wherever from 24 to 36 hours complete relying in your noise-canceling utilization. Benefit Sony within the battery life division.
ANC and transparency modes
Time to speak about lively noise-canceling — or ANC — and on the opposite finish of that, transparency mode. With regards to noise-canceling, the AirPods Professional and XM4 are very shut — so shut that I actually must name it a draw. Once I cranked up a loud field fan, the XM4 did a greater job of canceling the noise from shut proximity whereas the AirPods Professional did higher after I was additional away. I obtained the identical expertise when utilizing a loud lawnmower, so for airline flights, I feel each buds will work nice. Each additionally did a fairly good job of blocking out voices, road noise, and so on. So, both manner, I feel you’ll be very happy with the noise-canceling.
The AirPods Professional, nonetheless, have a barely superior transparency mode — they only get a bit nearer to the sound of not having earbuds in in any respect than the Sony handle. Nonetheless, the Sony do positive at piping in exterior noise, and since this isn’t an enormous class for me, I’m calling it a draw as soon as once more.
Name high quality
As for name high quality, it’s tremendous shut, however the Sony XM4 handle to eke out a win. The readability of your voice on the opposite finish is about the identical between the 2, however the XM4 do a greater job of canceling out the noise round you and managing wind noise — an even bigger downside for people who wish to experience a motorcycle or run whereas speaking. So, in noisy environments, the XM4 are the higher possibility. When you make calls on the road or take Zoom conferences with numerous of us speaking round you, you need the WF-1000XM4.
I’m about to get into sound high quality, however earlier than I do, I simply wish to focus on what I’ll name the “bells and whistles” class — or you may additionally say, “consumer options.”
The Sony XM4 are only a extra richly featured set of buds. For one factor, the Sony Headphones app offers numerous management over the sound high quality: You’ll be able to modify the power of noise-canceling and there’s strain compensation, which is nice for a extra pure really feel on flights. Then there’s the auto-transparency mode, which kicks in when the buds detect you talking, although I ought to level out that any loud noise will kick in that characteristic, and it drives me nuts after I’m mowing the garden and the earbuds go into transparency mode after I very particularly need them to cancel the noise. Luckily, you’ll be able to flip that characteristic off if you’d like.
Different options embody location detection, which goals to regulate the noise-canceling primarily based on the place you might be and the extent of noise in your environment. Whereas this sounds cool, I turned it off. Once I need noise canceling, I would like it full energy.
The app will even aid you ensure you get the right eartip match, and it helps Sony’s 360 Actuality Audio (360RA) spatial audio format, which is obtainable by streaming providers like Tidal and Amazon Music Limitless. It even has you’re taking photos of your ears to optimize the expertise.
The Sony XM4 kick the AirPods Professional to the curb in sound high quality.
All of these Sony bonuses are positive, however on the finish of the day, I feel there’s one thing to be mentioned for simplicity, so I don’t discover myself so wooed by all these bells and whistles.
As for hands-free assistant management — the XM4 will allow you to name up the Google Assistant and Amazon’s Alexa hands-free, however it is advisable press a button to name up Siri. On iPhone, although, the XM4 require a button press for any of them. Clearly, the AirPods Professional will allow you to name up Siri hands-free on an iPhone, and it’s a button press for the rest.
Sound high quality
Let’s not mince phrases right here, the Sony XM4 kick the AirPods Professional to the curb in sound high quality and, frankly, I’m not shocked. The XM3 did the identical. The XM4 have just a bit much less vitality within the excessive frequencies than the XM3, which I attribute to the froth eartips, however as soon as my ears relaxed into them, I wasn’t conscious of it.
Simon Cohen / Digital Traits
By all measures, the XM4 offer you richer, extra punchy, and linear bass, clear midrange for very clear vocals, and extra high-frequency element than you get with the AirPods Professional. So if sound high quality is crucial factor for you, there’s no query the Sony XM4 are the higher decide.
So .. time to reply the query: Are the Sony XM4 ok to switch the AirPods Professional as my go-to wi-fi buds? Truthfully, this was a troublesome name. The AirPods Professional are such an incredible device. They’re simply so utilitarian and well-rounded that I by no means discover myself complaining about them. However, however, the Sony XM4 sound so a lot better, I like that they name much less consideration to themselves, the ANC is nice, the battery life is a lot better, and so they supply extra options than the AirPods do.
In the long run, I’m holding the Sony round, however I don’t know that they’ll exchange my AirPods Professional. The AirPods are finest for enterprise, whereas the Sony XM4 are higher for pleasure. If I’m working, AirPods Professional; if I’m having fun with myself, it’s the Sony XM4. You might say the 2 pair up for the right mullet of audio. Enterprise up entrance, and celebration within the again.